A coalition of major food and beverage trade groups filed a lawsuit Friday seeking to halt a new Texas law that would require warning labels on products containing certain synthetic food additives. The American Beverage Association, Consumer Brands Association, National Confectioners Association, and FMI – The Food Industry Association – jointly lodged the suit, calling the proposed labels “false and misleading,” according to Reuters.
The legislation would mandate that affected products carry a prominent statement reading: “WARNING: This product contains an ingredient that is not recommended for human consumption by the appropriate authority in Australia, Canada, the European Union, or the United Kingdom.”
But the groups argue that none of those jurisdictions have formally designated the listed ingredients as “not recommended for human consumption,” and therefore the warning falsely implies a level of international disapproval that does not exist.
“The listed ingredients have been used safely in American foods and beverages for decades,” the associations said in their complaint. They contend the law forces companies to tell Texas shoppers something that is “simply not true,” creating unnecessary alarm and damaging consumer trust.
Industry leaders also warned the measure would drive up costs. Companies would be forced either to reformulate products or redesign packaging specifically for the Texas market, potentially affecting supply chains nationwide. Some of the ingredients targeted by the law, the plaintiffs note, have already been restricted or banned at the federal level, further complicating compliance.
